[p2pu-dev] Fwd: challenge adopters and mentors

Philipp Schmidt philipp at p2pu.org
Wed Sep 14 05:50:15 UTC 2011

Adding Chloe who is designing the assessments and can help navigate.

We talked about a "complete the challenge" badge recently - and the
idea was to have one badge that "fills up" (think of it as a cake and
each badge gives you an additional slice) as you complete them.


On 13 September 2011 20:54, Jessica Ledbetter
<jessica at jessicaledbetter.com> wrote:
> On Tue, Sep 13, 2011 at 2:26 PM, zuzel.vp <zuzel.vp at gmail.com> wrote:
>> The fragment of the last community call that mentions something about
>> badge adopters and assesments/badge logic is:
>>    "Adopt a challenge" potential has been discussed, and this might
>> be a way of having guru assessment, or somehow weight these people's
>> assessment
> I have that question on my list too. Since it's nonmoderated, there needs to
> be some check though. I'm thinking they have at least successfully completed
> the challenge. Successfully completed the challenge means they have received
> the badge. But maybe it's just the self-assessment "I completed" check for
> all the challenge's tasks.
>>    possible to use community members who are drafted to do this in
>> the first round
> Yes, we need to be able to allow people to be added via admin and bypass the
> usual path to adoption status.
>>    We will have enough people to adopt all the challenges as
>> "original adopters"
> Yes, that's what John said.
>> > ** All the interaction around mentoring will happen through emails so
>> > there will not be a mentor role
> I saw mentor role on a document but I think it was supposed to be 'adopter.'
> It's on my question list, I think. I'm double checking that list after work
> tonight and then sending it out for answers.
>> > * Adopt this challenge will be non-moderated.
>> > ** It will become a button (right now it is a link)
>> > ** The functionality behind this button is to add them to the "Need
>> > help? Peers that can help you with this challenge:"
> Makes sense.
>> > ** Adopters need to receive notifications about the activity on the
>> > challenge groups (the email notifications for challenge groups will
>> > work just like study group/courses).
> Right, that's on my list too about notifications. Since we don't have a
> wall, people will get it via email only or inbox (could be spammy) or maybe
> be able to visit a view that shows submissions that haven't been evaluated
> yet.
> Also, maybe we should clarify with "active" adopters. That way people aren't
> emailing those that haven't been on in a month. Not so big a deal for this
> release, but maybe in the future.
>> > ** I need input from Jessica, Erin or Chlor about the challenge
>> > adopter role because I thought they were mentioning this role on the
>> > assesment/badges design.
> Yes. It is one of the roles. It could be more weight but I think right now
> it's not. cc'd Chloe, Erin and Carla to make sure they see this :)
> They get notified though and are listed as helpers.
>> > ** How people leave the adopter role is not clear yet.
> True. That's on my list too. I guess we can have a setting in notifications
> like other places where we can at least cut down on emails until we figure
> that out.
> --
> Jessica Ledbetter
> http://jessicaledbetter.com
> _______________________________________________
> p2pu-dev mailing list
> p2pu-dev at lists.p2pu.org
> http://lists.p2pu.org/mailman/listinfo/p2pu-dev

More information about the p2pu-dev mailing list